Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Josh Zee

There are 183 Google hits for "Josh Zee". Most of them are Wikipedia mirror sites. He's a member of the band Protein which seems to exist, but he doesn't deserve an article. Acegikmo1 19:47, 27 Jul 2004 (UTC)

• Well, Protein (band) is in allmusic.com and launch.yahoo.com, and they're a signed band (Sony), so they certainly belong. I'm not that familiar with the standards for Wikipedia's music articles... how popular does a band have to be for its artists to get their own pages? What bugs me is that the band's article is a stub, there's no reason why "Josh Zee" can't be a section in that article. His article could be turned into a redirect to Protein's article, and he could be given a section there, until such time as the info on Protein and him become abundant enough to warrant seperate articles. So I vote merge and redirect. No delete, because I think wiki links to "Josh Zee" shouldn't show up in red. - Eisnel 18:01, 28 Jul 2004 (UTC)
• Redirect to Protein (band), and de-link the member's names from that article. IMHO, the standard for separate articles for members of bands would be a) if they are noteworthy for additional reasons, or b) if the band article is getting too large. Niteowlneils 19:50, 31 Jul 2004 (UTC)

This discussion is closed. Consensus to redirect. DJ Clayworth 16:43, 10 Aug 2004 (UTC)